Framework library · M&A and corporate strategy
Acquisition integration scorecard
An integration scorecard sets a handful of measures across finance, customers, people, operations, synergies and culture, each with its value at closing and the target the deal case promised. Progress is the share of the gap closed so far, compared with the share the plan expected by now. That comparison separates a measure that is simply early from one that is behind or moving the wrong way.
Use it when
- A deal has closed and the steering group needs one page that shows whether the integration is on track.
- The deal case promised specific results, such as synergies, retention or churn, and the board will ask about each one.
- Workstreams report in different formats and you need common measures, baselines and targets.
- You want early warning of customer churn or staff departures before they show up in revenue.
Avoid it when
- There is no integration plan yet. Build it first with post-merger integration. A scorecard measures progress against a plan.
- You need to size or re-base the synergies. Use the synergy assessment and bring its totals in as targets.
- The measures have no baseline. A target with no starting point cannot show progress. Take the baseline at closing or leave the measure out.
- The measure is meant to hold steady, such as keeping key staff. Progress towards a target does not work for a floor. Track it in a risk register with a trigger level instead.
How to run it
Choose two or three measures per dimension
Financial, customers, people, operations, synergies and culture. Prefer measures that move within a quarter, such as churn or support response times, over annual ones.
Take the baseline at closing
The value on the day the deal closed, from the same source you will use for the actuals. Changing the source later makes the progress figure meaningless.
Set the target and the expected path
The target comes from the deal case or the integration plan. For each update, write down how much of the gap the plan expected to be closed by now.
Update the actuals monthly
Each measure's owner updates it; finance checks the financial and synergy figures before the steering meeting.
Read progress against plan
Progress is the share of the gap from baseline to target closed so far. A measure 25 points or more behind the plan is red, and one 10 to 24 points behind is amber. Negative progress means it has moved the wrong way since closing.
Act on the reds
Every red measure gets a cause, an owner and an action at the next steering meeting. Every amber gets a date by which it must turn green.
Work through it
Answer the questions below, or load the worked example to see a finished one. The drawing updates as you type. Export the result as a PowerPoint deck, a Word document, an Excel workbook, a PDF or plain text.
What you type stays in this browser, so you can close the page and come back to it. It is not sent to Blue Prysm or anyone else, and the exports are made here, on your device. Privacy policy.
Mistakes to avoid
- Tracking only the synergies. Customer and staff losses come first and erode the value the synergies were meant to add.
- Too many measures. Past twenty, the steering group reads none of them closely.
- Rating against the final target with no regard to timing, so that every measure is red in month two and the colours stop meaning anything.
- Letting each owner choose the data source. Agree the source with finance at closing and keep it.
Where it comes from
No single originator: integration scorecards are common practice after a deal closes. They apply the logic of Robert Kaplan and David Norton's balanced scorecard, in which financial results are tracked alongside the customer, internal process, and innovation and learning measures that lead them ("The Balanced Scorecard: Measures That Drive Performance", Harvard Business Review, January to February 1992). Source.
Use it with
Work through it with us
The frameworks here are free to use as they stand. If you would rather work through the question behind this one with us, these are the ways an engagement starts.